| 1891 William Y. Mason
 Lawrence Welsh
 Michael Ward
 James Flanagan
 Edward M. Whitney
 
 1892
 Benjamin W. Hopper
 John E. Healy
 John P. Allen
 James J. Kelly
 
 1893
 John Evers
 
 1894
 Charles H. Lewis
 
 1895
 Nicholas Geiser
 John Delahanty
 Robert Gray
 Matthew E. Kelly
 J. J. Umschlag
 
 1896
 George Bragaw
 George E. Chown
 Josiah M. Whitney
 
 1897
 James A. Mahoney
 Joseph Kelly
 
 1899
 Thomas J. Murphy
 John Manning
 
 1900
 John Hahn
 William H. Delahanty
 
 1902
 John E. Donnelly
 Charles Segar
 | 1903 H. C. Korfmann
 Charles Muff
 Clare B. Whittemore
 George Livingston
 
 1904
 George Gibbons
 Jacob J. Horn
 
 1905
 Thomas Flanagan
 Ford C. Woodward
 Thomas H. Ward
 Thomas Sims
 
 1907
 Peter Lanagan
 B. H. Tompson
 Conrad Schlott
 George L. Casey
 Charles Cranfield
 John E. Tier
 Michael Mulligan
 John Horan
 
 1908
 H. C. Mencken, Jr.
 George A. Halsey
 John A. Tobin
 Anton Geiser
 B. J. McGowan
 Joseph Brown
 William F. Coffee
 Philip Ring
 Patrick J. Smith
 
 1909
 William Mende
 William Carlin
 Michael Delahanty
 
 1910
 Joseph L. Manning
 John R. Thompson
 Winfield S. Sturgis
 Charles E. Luckings
 John Galloway
 Samuel J. Mehrtens
 John Corrigan
 
 | 1911 Thomas McNamara
 John P. Hayes
 D. M. Tompson
 George Lorenz
 Fred T. Hallett
 W. H. Muchmore
 Owen J. Kavanagh
 Andrew Banner
 Louis Riehle
 John H. Phillips
 Hugh A. Smyth
 Thomas F. Darcy
 
 1912
 Martin Paaren
 W. J. McLean
 M. T. Mitchell
 Charles Livingston
 Robert H. Lee
 Robert Schlimbach
 
 1913
 George H. Smith
 Harry Hempstead
 James Scully
 Theodore Vanderbrandt
 Hugh Gray
 Bernard Yung
 
 1914
 Thomas McCarthy
 Edward King
 John Fish, Sr.
 Thomas Lawler
 William Lawler
 Charles W. Hallett, Sr.
 James Ingram
 Patrick J. Fogarty
 George J. White
 George Held
 Jacob Boch
 Rudolph Peseux
 Patrick J. Bannon
 
 1915
 John Maley
 
 
 |